Menu of Homestretch Steak House in Anderson, Indiana, USA

Menu Overview

Nestled within the lively atmosphere of Harrah's Hoosier Park in Anderson, Indiana, Homestretch Steak House offers a classic steakhouse experience that caters to both casual diners and discerning palates. The menu centers on prime cuts and refined comfort foods, with highlights like the Prime Rib, Filet Mignon, and their signature Lobster Bisque setting the tone for a memorable meal.

The Prime Rib is a standout, especially when enjoyed on weekends as Suz P recommends. Cooked to a perfect medium, it delivers rich, tender flavors that meld well with a side of béarnaise sauce or their reliable Loaded Baked Potato. The Filet Mignon boasts an impeccable sear and depth of flavor, as noted by Jason Lang, who praised its precise preparation and the depth it brought to his dining experience.

Seafood lovers will appreciate the offerings beyond steak, particularly the Pan-Seared Atlantic Salmon and the Cold Water Lobster Tail, which add a touch of elegance and variety to the menu. Jason’s mention of the 6oz Filet & Lobster combo highlights how well the kitchen balances surf and turf elements here.

The appetizer selection is a mixed bag: the Lobster Bisque earns high marks for its rich, velvety texture and bold flavor, confirmed by customers like Johnathan Paredes. However, some appetizers come across as small and askew in value when compared to the main dishes, a detail worth noting if you're minding portions or budget.

Homestretch’s sides and salads complement the protein-centric menu solidly. Grilled Asparagus, Wedge Salad, and Mashed Potatoes offer classic steakhouse simplicity that rounds out the meal without overshadowing the mains. The bacon Mac & Cheese, highlighted in one review, brings an unexpected, soulful twist that elevates the comfort food palette.

Desserts here are not to be overlooked. The menu features a variety of indulgent cakes—Carrot Cake, Red Velvet Cheesecake, and New York Cheesecake among them—with prices consistently around $11.99. Jason Lang’s praise of their cheesecake confirms that the sweets hit all the right notes for a satisfying finish.

What truly distinguishes Homestretch Steak House is the service. Multiple patrons have noted the exceptional attentiveness and warmth of the staff. Cheryl, a noted server, and Brent, who patrols the dining room to ensure everything meets guests' expectations, embody the high standard of hospitality that often makes the difference between a good meal and a memorable one. This genuine care shines through even when the service pace occasionally falters.

While some diners find the experience a tad pricey and the appetizers modest in portion, the combination of quality beef, thoughtful seafood options, and truly stellar service creates a compelling destination for both steak aficionados and families alike. Whether you're there to indulge after a day at the casino or to enjoy the thrill of live horse racing, Homestretch Steak House serves up a warm and satisfying meal that invites repeat visits.